In 2015, when Fat Kid Deli opened in Navi Mumbai, the burger joint began to grow in popularity not just for the size of its burgers but also for the impassioned replies of its co-founder and head chef Ranjiv Sahni to negative reviews on the Zomato website.
When someone ticked him off with a poor review, Sahni responded, “It’s on the fricking menu you visually challenged people! It’s mentioned what the burger comes with and what not. Just because I’m running a business here does not mean I should take any crap that you’ll talk.”
A year later, Kaliash Patil, the assistant manager at the restaurant, acknowledges that Sahni lost his temper, but attributes the fury to the fact that “our chef was 23 years old when he set up the restaurant”. “He is a passionate guy,” Patil said. “For him, someone insulting his food is like someone insulting a child." Another reason for the annoyance, Patil claims, was that Fat Kid Deli had brought new ingredients to Navi Mumbai, an area where not many restaurants had “complex menus”.
So if people complained about the use of wasabi or its spiciness, Sahni and the restaurant felt the need to respond.
Something similar happened in the case of Cafe Terra, a fine dining restaurant on the terrace of the Executive Enclave Hotel in the Mumbai neighbourhood of Bandra.
A food blogger rated the place a poor 2.0 on Zomato because it did not have a proper Jain menu and because he alleged its food gave his friends and him a stomach bug. The review sparked a flurry of comments, some of which picked a debate with the food blogger, who is also a Zomato connoisseur (the title is given to users with the most number of reviews with a large number of likes on the service).
Cafe Terra’s owner Monish Rohra says he didn’t have a problem with the review, but he did take issue with the connoisseur tag given by Zomato. “A connoisseur means you are an expert. How can you be an expert when you want Italian food without garlic, which is what the entire cuisine is based around?”
Why did the restaurants or their owners react to individual reviews? Because, in the world of crowd-sourced opinion, each one can damage equally.
Set up in 2008, the restaurant discovery service Zomato has grown relatively quickly, spreading to 23 countries and listing close to 75,000 restaurants across 12 Indian cities. In its current form, it allows users to browse through menus, write reviews and rate restaurants. The website has also recently started an online home deliver service. Deepinder Goyal, one of the service’s founders, claimed in an interview last year that Zomato gets over one crore unique visitors each month.
Even a string of bad news has not diminished its popularity. Although its billion dollar valuation was halved, its online delivery services was shut down in four Indian cities, and it laid off 300 employees last October, it is still the biggest player in the food ratings industry.
Indeed, such is its enviable popularity that many restaurants keep aside a marketing budget for it. “In the days before Zomato, the buzz was created through print media and advertisements,” Rohra said. “But this time most of our marketing budget was reserved for Zomato.”
The service connects users to restaurants and vice-versa. For instance, menus can either be uploaded on Zomato by restaurants themselves or through a company team that visits them and collects information. While restaurants do not have to pay to get featured or reviewed on Zomato, they do have to pay to get one of the top spots in the collections that group restaurants on the home page.
The reviews, meanwhile, can be uploaded by anyone. Its website home page lists the top food bloggers, reviewers and photographers, all of whom have been ranked based on the number of reviews or photographs they submit. Each review gets 25 points plus an additional bonus point for every 10 likes on a review. With more reviews, and more points, the likelihood of being upgraded to a top reviewer or connoisseur is greater. It is often these reviewers who get invited to restaurant openings and are called to write the first reviews.
Good reviews and ratings also lead to a better overall score out of five.
Kumar Jhuremalani, co-founder of Pet Pujaris, a community of foodies that organises trips to try restaurants and cuisines, says he visits establishments even with a low rating but it does give him pause. “Anything below three, I will think twice about going there,” he said.
For Patil, the rating threshold is four stars. And for Rohra, the owner of Cafe Terra, it is “anything above 3.5, although I am not a big fan of how their algorithm works. We have many four and five star reviews and yet our restaurant is rated a 3.7.”
It is this widespread reliance on Zomato’s star system for discovery of restaurants that makes restaurateurs take it so seriously – too many poor reviews and low ratings by reviewers and the overall score drops to an undesirable degree. Which, in turn, means that prospective patrons stay away.
For restaurants with large reputations and deep pockets, this system can be detrimental but not necessarily fatal. They often employ social media agencies to reply on their behalf with stock responses – “thank you for commenting” to a positive review and “we are sorry” to a negative one.
However, for mid-sized restaurants, the star system can be the difference between survival and closure. That is partly why they feel compelled to respond to each review, sometimes with forcefulness and vehemence.
A negative review of Barbarian, a home-delivery service in Matunga East that promises to serve food till 3 am, went something like this: “To the management of Barbarian – the pizza on the right is your infamous Triplet. Eat a little dogshit mixed with tabasco and let me know if you can tell the difference. To all you future patrons of Barbarian – if you want to kill yourself barbarically, eat here.”
The management’s response was equally vitriolic: “You may not order again perhaps we dont need any guest’s like you !! wo r drunk and abuse our staff’s at delivery !! lol please we request you don’t order again!!!! (sic)”
It is not that negative reviews lead to fights every time. Often, restaurants call back the patrons for a free meal. This review of 1Tablespoon, a pizza shop with two outlets in Mumbai, is a good example of the amicability. “I usually never score any restaurants below 3 unless it was a complete disappointment and I felt that I wasted all the money,” wrote a user. “I wish they improvise on their sauce and the cheese texture.”
The restaurant responded by calling the reviewer back, showing them how the pizza was made, what kind of ovens were used, and conceding that they might have missed a beat on the day of the critic’s visit. As a result, the rating with the review was upgraded to 3.5.
Zomato’s model of user-generated content comes from Yelp, the popular American service set up in 2004 which publishes crowd-sourced reviews of local businesses and services. Yelp gets close to 145 million unique visitors every month and has around 102 million reviews. It is often criticised for asking customers to pay for better reviews, the reported surfeit of fake reviews and a complicated relationship with small businesses. A report in the Los Angeles Times described a restaurant with a sign outside that read, “Our customers repeatedly tell us they have submitted very good reviews that never show up on the website. We asked Yelp. We were told ‘perhaps if you paid to do Yelp ads, we could help with this.’“
Yelp has also been used as the site of protest, a trend that the company itself frowns upon. In the aftermath of the killing of Cecil the Lion in Zimbabwe by American dentist Walter Palmer, numerous one-star reviews of the dentist’s office littered Yelp.
It is irrefutable that Yelp and Zomato have provided customers a voice on an open forum that anyone with an internet connection can access. But restaurant owners, who often feel shortchanged, wonder if every opinion is worthy.
“One Saturday night when we got busy, a person who did not get a table for a long time reviewed us from the restaurant and gave us one star,” Rohra said.
Jhuremalani recalled another review, which read “There is no valet parking. So I left”. It came with a rating of one.
Then, there have been instances of Zomato critics demanding free food in return for a positive review. In May, a top critic alleged that the company asked restaurants to pay for reviews and had deleted his profile because he became an independent contractor.
He wrote: “Now, Zomato’s ‘verified reviewers’ (you know the ones with blue & white stars on their DPs) come into picture here. Zomato invites these guys to do review under the pretext of “Zomato Meetups”. These guys eat to their heart’s content for free, and subsequently reward the restaurant with high ratings and positive reviews.”
The company’s version was that since he asked for money, the reviews were fake and they had to consequently delete the account.
Conversely, a Zomato critic who also runs a popular blog and an Instagram account, says that some restaurants expect a positive review just because they have invited you for a free meal.
A large number of apps in the sharing economy have begun to rate their users. For instance, at the end of every ride in an Uber or Ola cab, the driver rates the rider, just as the rider rates the driver. After a stay in an Airbnb apartment, the owner too gets to rate the renter. This creates a level-playing field for both the service provider and user – it draws a line that does not exist on user-generated review apps as yet. On Zomato, restaurateurs can only respond to critics, not rate them.
Besides, quite a few of the reviews are not even specific. There are positive five-star reviews that say, “The food was good and I had a good time.” Many reviews talk about the ambience and lighting. They are mostly generalised opinions, aired decisively from the safe distance of the internet. “About 70 per cent of reviews on Zomato are vague – ‘We liked the food. The ambience was good’,” Patil complained. “For reviews like that we don’t feel the need to respond.”
Another frequent complaint of restaurant owners and a point raised both by Patil and Rohra is that customers write negative reviews on Zomato despite telling them in person that the meal was alright and that they had a good time. Jhuremalani blames the website for creating this atmosphere.Scroll.in reached out to Zomato’s public relations team for comment but they did not get back.
Food is a major industry in India with television channels, YouTube channels and Instagram accounts devoted to it. A large number of followers means entry into the hallowed ranks of so-called influencers that allows a passion for food to become a career. For restaurants too, Zomato is the cheapest and easiest ways to get noticed.
“Restaurants should stop responding through social media agencies,” Jhuremalani said. “A trend needs to start where a restaurant chef starts responding to reviews. That might improve the community.”
SOURCE: Scroll
Police NOCs Not Required For The Following:
1. Eating House Registration Certificate.
2. Swimming Pool License.
3. Place Of Public Entertainment License [PPEL-A]
4. Place Of Public Entertainment License [PPEL-B]
5. Performance License.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, CLICK HERE!
Related Articles - Restaurants Timings Circular - CLICK HERE
Police Commissioner Rakesh Maria clears proposal to allow restaurants, bars, pubs to serve all night
Swachh Bharat Abhiyan on 30th January 2015 by the AHAR members
Industry Says Ground Water May Be To Blame
A rigid adherence to parking space rules might lead to the closing down of many establishments in Mumbai, the Bombay high court said, setting aside the police commissioner's order
The 2nd Managing Committee Meeting of AHAR will be held on Thursday 29th January 2015 at 7.00 p.m. sharp in Krishna Palace Residency Hotel, Spelling relief for hotels and establishments in city malls, Mumbai Police commissioner Rakesh Maria recently ordered the Hotel Branch of the city police to not turn down requests for police licences from such establishments. We spent 24 hours with pure-bred Bengali chefs to learn everything there is to about river water fish. NOTICE TO MEMEBRS The Managing Committee meeting of AHAR hosted by Zone 6 will be held on
MUMBAI: To achieve its goal of making the city garbage-free, the BMC plans to organize a Swachh Mumbai For Swachh Bharat Week awareness campaign which will involve everyone&m MUMBAI: To achieve its goal of making the city garbage-free, the BMC plans to organize a Swachh Mumbai For Swachh Bharat Week awareness campaign which will involve everyone&m MUMBAI: To achieve its goal of making the city garbage-free, the BMC plans to organize a Swachh Mumbai For Swachh Bharat Week awareness campaign which will involve everyone&m Under the Swachhata Abhiyaaan Programme, the Staff of MOH, MCGM will be visiting & taking photographs of Under the Swachhata Abhiyaaan Programme, the Staff of MOH, MCGM will be visiting & taking photographs of Commuters on the new Mumbai Metro can now experience the flavour of Kerala with a ‘Kerala Green Express’ running on the network under a branding agreement with the state tourism department. Kerala has beco Commuters on the new Mumbai Metro can now experience the flavour of Kerala with a ‘Kerala Green Express’ running on the network under a branding agreement with the state tourism department. Kerala has become the first destination In the light of certain non compliance in the Food Safety Act which was proposed by the previous Union Government to Food Safety and Standards Act 2006. In the light of certain non compliance in the Food Safety Act which was proposed by the previous Union Government to Food Safety and Standards Act 2006. A decision to withdraw the existing amendments to this Act was taken on Wednesday 5th November 2014 What are the options Mumbai throws up if hunger strikes you at 5 am? We arose before sunrise to find out. What are the options Mumbai throws up if hunger strikes you at 5 am? We arose before sunrise to find out. We have all seen, at least once, twilight transform from pitch blackness to the dull gray of dawn through bloodshot eye Winter is coming. No, we are not talking about the title of the first episode of Game of Thrones, but Undhiyu, an indulgent Gujarati delicacy made of winter greens, whose season begins in mid-November and goes on till February. Phorum Dalal chats with& Winter is coming. No, we are not talking about the title of the first episode of Game of Thrones, but Undhiyu, an indulgent Gujarati delicacy made of winter greens, whose season begins in mid-November and goes on till February. Phorum Dalal chats with Fire Safety & Prevention Info & Demo has been arranged for benefit of all Restauranteurs ./Owners/Sr. Managers. The Cabinet today at the meeting chaired by the Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi gave its approval for withdrawing the Food Safety and Standards (Amendment) Bill, 2014 as introduced in the Rajya Sabha on 19.02.2014. The plan to controlling brain chemicals that'll decide how happy you'll be today. The plan to controlling brain chemicals that'll decide how happy you'll be today. Kerala high court on Friday stayed the single bench's decision to close down 250 bars The Kerala high court on Thursday dismissed petitions filed by two-star and three-star bar hotels
AHAR has been at the forefront in guarding interests of hoteliers and restaurant owners across India. I congratulate them on their efforts and wish them good luck for all their endevours.
The F&B and hospitality industry : sourcing . networking . celebrating at FHW Mumbai 2015
The F&B and hospitality industry : sourcing . networking . celebrating at FHW Mumbai 2015
The 2nd Managing Committee Meeting
Maharashtra: Hotels want ‘outdated’ drinking permit system to be scrapped
FDA satisfied with New Yr's Eve food
Nearly 200 bars reopen in Kerala
Waiter, there's a bug in my grub
US co taken to court for using Bapu's image for its beer brand
No increase in rates at bars, clubs with exodus from Mumbai
Now, hotels and pubs asked to ensure patrons don’t park cars on roads
City cops demand fresh fire audit of hotels and bars
From next year, hotels may serve food, liquor on terrace
Transport office cracks down on delivery bikes
Pancakes to pesarattu and poha
‘Don’t withhold hotel licences over parking’ : Rakesh Maria
A Start Fresh
NOTICE TO MEMEBRS
BMC to kick off awareness drive for trash-free Mumbai today
BMC to kick off awareness drive for trash-free Mumbai today
BMC to kick off awareness drive for trash-free Mumbai today
Dear Members,
Swachhata Abhiyaaan Programme
Test
Kerala Tourism joins hands with Mumbai Metro
Kerala Tourism joins hands with Mumbai Metro
Cabinet Nod to Withdraw Changes to Food Safety Act
Cabinet Nod to Withdraw Changes to Food Safety Act
Grub at dawn
By Sanjiv Nair
Grub at dawn
Food special: Undhiyu - Delectable, demystified
Food special: Undhiyu - Delectable, demystified
Fire Safety & Prevention Info & Demo
Withdrawal of the Food Safety and Standards (Amendment) Bill, 2014
Acme Oasis, Kandivali
Acme Oasis, Kandivali
Mood foods
Kerala HC revises bar closure order
Kerala HC upholds ban on bars `partially'
Now, Gujarat’s hotels can issue tourist liquor permits
Maska goes modern
Poll Maal: Cheers, booze after 6pm on polling, counting days
Tunday Kebabs in Rs 50 crore law suit over trade infringement
Reprieve for Kerala bar owners: Don't cancel bar licences yet, SC tells govt
PF
The Science of Structuring your menu right
States high on alcohol report decline in drunk driving deaths
Former Maharashtra FDA chief is new transport department head
The unhappy hour
Fight against ajinomoto continues
Whisky hunters scour globe for rare malts
DA Circular 1st July 2014 to 31st December 2014
DA Circular 1st January 2014 to 30th June 2014
Minimum pension of Rs 1,000 under EPFO; wage ceiling up at Rs 15,000
Kerala prohibition: No ban on wine in churches
'WHO says alcohol prohibition doesn't work'
Bar owners to take Kerala govt to court for ‘wrecking the Rs 20k crore industry’
ALL BOTTLED UP - Unhappy Hours
SLICE OF HISTORY - First luxury hotel traced to UK village
Licence Raj Has no Room: Approvals for Hotels Eased
Kerala, India’s Top Consumer of Liquor, Heads for Prohibition
Mobile liquor shop under excise dept nose, one held
Tata Power to back BEST case for transport subsidy
In farewell letter, ex-FDA chief slams corruption in dept
BEST’s power monopoly ends, Tata enters Mumbai
Condolence Meeting Of Shri. Prithviraj Sundar Shetty, Vice President of AHAR Zone - IV
Table Tablet Menu Technology in Restaurant
PIL Urges Scrapping of ‘Archaic’ and ‘Superfluous’ Liquor Permit System in Maharashtra
[Video] Signs Restaurant in Toronto, Canada with deaf servers encourages customers to place order in signs language
Police ordered not to disturb bars till 1.30am closing time
Tipplers take to streets for Fix
Loose edible oil safe, but 2/3rd of samples impure
Crossing the tippling point
HC relief for eateries on licence to play music
Home deliveries bite instant foods
Login, meals ready
Advertise with Us
How to Grow Your Restaurant Business Using Online Listing
Water supply to star hotels, malls cut by 50% in Mumbai
No rollback of service tax in budget, Mumbai hoteliers upset
Post your queries
A new cocktail calculator that tells alcohol content of your drink
Delayed rain may hit beer output in Maharashtra
Meeting With Shri. Gopal Shetty, MP
Food authority advisory unlawful, says Bombay high court
TRAI Matters
Mumbai hotels want to play on till 3.30am for World Cup
HC kicks out demand to tax World Cup in eateries
From AHAR to Prime Minister of India
Chouhan urges PM to convene meeting of CMs on Food Safety Act
Shifting Electricity Provider from BEST to TATA Power
Cross subsidy, regulatory asset charges make changeover consumer category uncompetitive
Why Mumbaikars will continue to pay high tariffs to power companies
Praful Patel trashes ban on dance bars
Will apps spell the end of waiters in restaurants?
Bar dancers in Maharashtra pin their hopes on BJP
Mumbai Can Party Till 5am on New Year, High Court Rules
Maharashtra Cabinet Approves New Law to Ban Dance Bars
Dance bar ban to continue
Amended Law may not Stand Legal Challenge
State takes dance off the floor in 5-stars too
What Can Mumbaiites Do to Save Their Nightlife
5 BRANDING TIPS FOR Small RESTAURANTS
Why Restaurants In Mumbai Are Shutting Down?
AHAR Blog
Restaurants Fume Over Lack of Rs Five Coins
OFF THE BEATEN TRACK BARTENDER Learn to mix the drink, shaken or stirred
Dance bar girls, owners welcome SC move
BEST to lose monopoly over SoBo’s power supply
The Single-Minded Mr Patil
test
Hoteliers Cook Up Recipe to Bail Out Ailing Restaurants
Craft Designer Desserts, Fashion Edible Artpieces For A Calling
Tata Power’s Consumer Base Goes Up to 5 Lakh
The Right Blend: USL Tie-up Helps Johnnie Walker Run in India
State Govt. Can Regulate Dance Bars, Not Ban Them’
Breaking of BEST Monopoly After 5 Long Years Battle.
SC Ruling May Hit BEST’s Low-End Power Consumers
Patil Wants Dance Bar Patrons To Go Hungry
Maharashtra Govt Plans New Bill To Ban Dance Bars In Mumbai
Archives
Patil: Govt to Rework Dance Bar Laws
90 Restaurants Refuse To Renew Bar Licences
State, Patil get contempt notices for ‘defying’ SC order on dance bars
Pillsbury Offer
Sahara Q Shop Offer
Mercedes Benz Offer
Mercedes Benz Offer
AHAR Promotions
Mumbai's Bar Code
Vote for Better Government, Vote for Better India
Shetty openly backing eatery encroachments
No Need to Post Cops In Bars: HC
Excise Archives
abc
Another Iconic Irani Joint Bites the Dust in Mumbai
One Industry One Voice
Owners of Bars, Eateries Threaten Not to Renew Licence
Maharashtra's Permit Raj Dampens Spirits, Nets Paltry Rs 3.5 Cr.
State Forms Committee to Look Into Hoteliers' Grievances
Restaurateurs Not Happy With Interim Budget; Concern Over Service Tax
What Can Mumbaiites Do to Save their Nightlife
Painful Taxes Force 100 Mumbai Bars to Shut
Bars, Restaurants Say Sheers to Easy Licensing System
EXCISE License UPDATE
Hotels Seek Withdrawal of Excise Licence Hike
Strike a balance, ensure it’s business as usual at bars, restaurants: HC to cops
AHAR Panel Of Consultants
82-year-old Lalbaug Eatery to Shut Shop
Officer’s Choice, Royal Stag in $1bn Club
Will not renew licences till HC verdict: hoteliers
AHAR CONNECT NEWSLETTER
Court Orders / Judgements
Sub - Committees AHAR 2013 - 2014
Why post cops at bars? Let them maintain law and order at bus stops: High Court
NO EXCISE LICENCE RENEWAL
Why you should Exchange PRE- 2005 Currency Notes
Connect with AHAR
AHAR Connect Jan 2014
Liquor may get costlier in Maharashtra
Liquor to become dearer as licence fee goes up by 50%
BEST power consumers pay for transport wing’s losses
Wages & D.A. Chart
Heavy Taxes on the Liquor Industry
Rate cards of Mumbai eateries double in 5 years
Quick Service Restaurant chains go deep on promotions
AHAR Impact
Flood of complaints from Mumbai citizens makes Sitaram Kunte give an earful to BMC ward officers
Press Release
AHar in Media
Shop Owners in Chember Register Extortion Complaint against AMC
Gajalee Canopy Safe for Time Being
Follow hygiene rules or face the music: FDA to roadside vendors
Food Safety Act not implementable in toto
FDA sees red after eatery adds colour to chicken lollypop
About Us - Continue
Monthly Meetings
Power bill relief to early birds was short-lived
Does your power bill shock you?
FSSAI/FDA CAMP AT AHAR OFFICE
AHAR Hospitality
Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai Solid Waste Management Department
90 Udupi eateries shut shop in 2 years
Court Orders / Judgement
Zone Committee
Ex-Office Bearers
Others
Service Tax
VAT - Service Tax
EXCISE
POLICE
FSSAI
BMC
What's AHAR
Past Presidents
Sub-Committees 2014 - 2015
Team Ahar
AGM Reports
HC snubs police chief, lets Mumbai party till 5am
High court order puts a smile on hoteliers' faces
AHAR won the case in Mumbai High Court against withdrawal of extension of timing by Commissioner of Police
Eight things to do before you head out to the party
Party’s moved to Navi Mumbai
Bombay high court to rule on hotels deadline today
AHAR's appeal against withdrawal of Extension of Timing
Hoteliers Request Cops to Review Deadline
Cops play party poopers; New Year parties to end at 1.30 am
Mumbai cops say no to extended revelry on 31st
Social Responsibility
PRESIDENT’S NOMINEE FOR FELICITRATIONS
Dr Rashmi kolhe
Extension of timing for the 24, 25 & 31st december, 2013
Important Notification
Seminars
SHRI VASANT SHETTY
FELICITATIONS TO SENIOR HOTELIERS
AHAR AGM
Exhibitions
Office Bearers
Count Orders / Circulars
Circulars
Notification No 16 /2013-Service Tax
Panel of Consultants
Zone X
Zone IX
Zone VIII
Zone VII
Zone VI
Zone V
Zone IV
Zone III
Zone II
Zone I
Connect with the AHAR community & know more about us
AHAR Connect Dec 2013
Contact
AHAR B2B
Media Room
Events
Resource Centre
Initiatives
Members
18th December, 2013
Website Launched
Managing Director
John Franklin
Committee & Zones
About Us
Welcome To Indian Hotel And Restaurant Association (AHAR)
© Copyright, Indian Hotel & Restaurant Association All Rights Reserved
Powered by:
eRegnow